We read in the last essay that David dealt harshly with Rechab and Baanah, murderous thugs who slayed King Ishbosheth, Saul’s son. Comeuppance came swiftly. Summarily, King David executed both assassins. Samuel 5 records David’s first official acts as the widely-supported ruler over all the Children of Israel.

”Then came all the tribes of Israel to David unto Hebron, and spoke, saying: Behold, we are your bone and your flesh.”

Naturally, the spiritual Hebrew king set his sights on Jerusalem. After all, it is the pride and joy of the Holy Land – its crown jewel. At that time, and while David still operated the kingdom from Hebron, a formidable occupying force stood in David’s way: the Jebusites. “And the king and his men went to Jerusalem against the Jebusites, the inhabitants of the land…”

Abravanel begins the chapter with two questions:

  • Why was there a need to liberate Jerusalem? Hadn’t the tribes of Judah and Benjamin already subdued the Jebusites? 
  • How should we understand the Jebusites’ words to David after he and his soldiers reached Jerusalem. “The inhabitants of the land, who spoke unto David, saying: Except you take away the blind and the lame, you shall not come in hither; thinking: David cannot come in hither.” What is meant by the Jebusite puzzling allusion to “the blind and the lame” defenders? Moreover, how could a considerably compromised category of society stop a mighty monarch and his men?

In his commentary to the Book of Judges, Abravanel posits that Jerusalem and Jebusite land refers to a sizeable, contiguous territorial tract. Part of it was controlled by the tribe of Judah, after driving out one Jebusite resistance: “And the Children of Judah fought against Jerusalem, and took it, and smote it with the edge of the sword, and set the city on fire.” (Judges 1). Benjamin fared considerably worse. “And the Children of Benjamin did not drive out the Jebusites that inhabited Jerusalem; but the Jebusites dwelt with the Children of Benjamin in Jerusalem, unto this day.” (Ibid).

When King David ascended the throne, he confronted a reality of a partitioned Jerusalem/Jebusite
region. This clumsy and undesirable arrangement simply would not do. For David, Hebrews needed to
control the Holy City – exclusively. The king’s attitude reflected a long-held tradition that Jerusalem was
designated by Above to house His Holy Temple.

Abravanel infuses more terminology regarding the Jerusalem/Jebusite discussion. It is that the Jebusite “stronghold” or “Citadel” refers to one and the same place. Let’s clarify. When King David and his warriors captured the stronghold/Citadel from the Jebusites, that fortress received its new, eternal appellation; it’s Zion/City of David. This is borne out by text: “Nevertheless David took the stronghold of Zion; the same is the City of David.” In Hebrew, the term “Zion” means remarkable or outstanding. Indeed, and as stated above, Zion or the City of David rates as Israel’s storied legacy. No place in the Holy Land (or elsewhere) compares. In this way, Abravanel supplies us with a useful historical overview of the City of David – Jerusalem.

We now move on to our next topic. What precisely did the Jebusite’s want to convey to David as he stood within earshot of the Citadel? “The inhabitants of the land, who spoke unto David, saying: Except you take away the blind and the lame, you shall not come in hither; thinking: David cannot come in hither.” For Abravanel, the defending Jebusites’ boisterous chant intended to intimidate, nay rattle, the Hebrew king. Proof of the hyperbole may be adduced by the literary repetition: “You shall not come in hither” and “David cannot come in hither.” Cocksure the Jebusites were – under no circumstances will David overcome the city’s advanced defense system.

Jebusites elaborated. “Except you take away the blind and the lame…” They meant that the defenders would put up every last man to repel David’s onslaught. So high was the Jebusite’s morale, so motivated were the city folk, that every man – able bodied or otherwise – would make a heroic stand. There was another element to the Jebusite challenge: the location. The place served as their pagan capital, their holy haunt.

In sum, Abravanel illustrates the meaning of the Jebusite’s feisty fighting words, on the eve of the campaign. Bluster, however, goes only so far. It is no match for the God of Israel. “Nevertheless David took the stronghold of Zion; the same is the city of David…for the LORD, the God of hosts, was with him.”