• Abravanel’s World of Torah

    Abravanel’s World of Torah

    is an enticingly innovative yet thoroughly loyal rendition of a major fifteenth-century Hebrew classic.
    For the first time, Don Yitzchak Abravanel’s Bible commentary has become accessible IN ENGLISH.
      

The Book of Judges

  • Book of Judges 1: Urim and Thummim

    To preface, Abravanel makes an assumption, regarding the first verse in Judges 1 – “that the Children of
    Israel asked the LORD.” That is, he took it for granted that the nation consulted with the Urim and
    Thummim. This is the breastplate which the priests wore when consulting God. In Biblical parlance, then, posing a question of national importance to God and getting an
    answer from Him came down to seeking counsel or advice from the Urim and Thummim. Of course, the
    pressing matter at hand referred to military leadership.

    “And it came to pass after the death of Joshua, that the Children of Israel asked
    the LORD, saying: Who shall go up for us first against the Canaanites, to fight
    against them? And the LORD said: Judah shall go up. Behold, I have delivered
    the land into his hand.”

    After Joshua’s death, things changed. Front and center stood the question of succession: Who would
    serve as the people’s top soldier, the Hebrews wanted to know? Abravanel teaches that we must
    understand something here. Namely, given that the Holy Land had been allocated amongst the twelve
    tribes, boundaries settled, why had the question of succession surfaced in the first place? Let each tribe
    fend for themselves, Abravanel advances. Why, then, had there been a call for a centralized chain of
    military command? Better, each tribe should take charge – and responsibility – for their security
    requirements. Call it a divide and conquer approach to ousting Canaanite pockets, one tribe at a time.

    Abravanel adds this. Imagine. Had all the tribes pursued those respective areas where enemies held out
    – simultaneously – that would have delivered a death knell to stubborn resistance. Well, sort of, if we
    assume best-case-scenario. That is, if all twelve tribes defeated their respective enemy, strongholds
    then there would be no safe haven for Canaanites anywhere in the Holy Land, seeing that each tribe put
    their foes to the sword. Thus, the enemy would have surrendered, scattered, or fled. Needless to say, no
    Canaanite alliance would be forged as warriors hastily headed to the border. Point being: Much could be
    said for decentralization, where each tribe fended for themselves. But if the argument for
    decentralization had been carried out, with cross-the-board success, why ask for a central command?

    Before Abravanel addresses that point, he shares something else. “And it came to pass after the death
    of Joshua, that Children of Israel asked the LORD…”Why the prefatory remark regarding the timing of
    the question – that it took place after Joshua’s passing? From the verse, it appears that Joshua had not
    consulted the Urim and Thummim during his tenure.

    Abravanel answers his two questions in order. Seemingly, decentralization had never been attempted –
    at least in Joshua’s time. And so, while autonomous tribal military sounded good on paper, it had yet to
    be established. Given that, the nation clamored to know who would lead this first battle (post Joshua)
    because of the vital importance attributed to it; it set the tone for all ensuing battles. Had the Jews
    collectively marched out to fight, and then been beat, the Gentiles would say that the Jews lost divine
    support. In effect, that boost would lead the enemies to redouble efforts to wrest the Holy Land away
    from the Children of Israel. However, if the Hebrews emerged victorious in this first confrontation, even
    after Joshua had died, enemy forces would lose heart. They would understand that the Jews are a force
    to be reckoned with, as previously. For that reason, Abravanel teaches, the people needed to know who
    would lead the war efforts in this do-or-die campaign.

    “And the LORD said: Judah shall go up.” Heaven gave the nod to Judah; he would command the troops.
    When word got out that Judah would fight at the vanguard, fear would debilitate Canaanites. Now, one
    Bible commentator posited that Joshua, too, had used the Urim and Thummim. Abravanel disagrees.
    Here’s why.

    Let us backup to the Book of Numbers (chapter 27). In it we find that God spoke to Moses, regarding
    Joshua, his successor. “And he shall stand before Eleazar the priest, who shall inquire for him by the
    judgment of the Urim before the LORD.” However, Abravanel contends, the Maker desired to raise
    Joshua’s prominence in the eyes of his brethren. One way God did that was by opening up prophetic
    channels to Joshua. Even a superficial reading of the Book of Joshua reveals several verses featuring just
    that – God’s explicit messaging to him. Since the Maker kept open lines of communication with Joshua,
    there would be no need for him to call Eleazar the priest and have him pose a question for Joshua.

    Yet, after Joshua’s death, owing to the fact that prophecy had dried up, so to speak, the Hebrews called
    on the Urim and Thummim to settle matters of national importance, chief among them: Who would
    lead the nation to war?

  • Judges 10: Hebrew Judges Tola and Jair

    “And after Abimelech there arose to save Israel Tola the son of Puah, the son of
    Dodo, a man of Issachar; and he dwelt in Shamir in the hill-country of Ephraim.
    And he judged Israel twenty and three years, and died, and was buried in
    Shamir.”

    As we read in the previous chapter, Abimelech died. Who was Tola, judge number 7 and his successor? Abravanel
    provides two possibilities. Tola was the son of Puah, as our chapter’s lead verse conveys. But
    what do the words “son of Dodo” mean? One possibility is that “dodo” is not Tola’s
    grandfather, but rather “dodo” should be translated lower case, teaching that Tola and
    Abimelech were cousins. In Hebrew, “dod” is uncle. Tola, then, was the son of Puah and a
    cousin (son of the uncle) to Abimelech. This is in keeping with an ancient Biblical commentator.
    Alternatively, Dodo was indeed a man’s name, making him Tola’s grandfather.

    After judging the Hebrews for twenty-three years, Tola passed away “and was buried in Shamir.
    And after him arose Jair, the Gileadite; and he judged Israel twenty and two years”, just one
    year shy of Tola’s tenure, Abravanel notes.

    Jair as judge number 8 was prolific. “And he had thirty sons who rode on thirty ass colts, and they had thirty cities,
    which are called Havvoth-jair unto this day, which are in the land of Gilead.” Commentators
    point out that our verse makes use of literary or poetic language. In Hebrew, the word for “ass
    colts” is nearly identical with the word for “cities.” Actually, poetic license comes into play
    when we consider the Hebrew (mis-) spelling of cities or “ayarim.” Technically, it should have
    been “arim.” Hence, the play on words for ass colts and cities. Either way, “ayarim” or “arim”
    refer to unwalled cities.

    But, Abravanel wonders, what is the significance of the verse conveying Jair’s large family
    (thirty sons) and large real estate holdings (thirty cities)? The description implies that Jair was a
    magnate, a grandee. Each of Jair’s thirty sons, too, were elites. They saddled up and stood
    behind Jair, riding as a unified unit, a most impressive one at that.

    Abravanel hypothesizes, that on account of Jair’s fruitfulness and opulence, the Hebrews
    turned to him and promoted him to judgeship. Another interesting tidbit. Ass colts, in those
    days, were considered status symbols, flashy animals upon which to ride. Jair and sons traveled
    via these ass colts, or as Abravanel teaches, mules – female and male mules.

    In short fashion, Judges deals with Jair. “And Jair died, and was buried in Kamon.” The next
    chapter will have much more to say about Jephthah, the upcoming judge.

  • Judges 11: Yiftach (Jephthah) the Gileadite

    “Now Yiftach the Gileadite was a mighty man of valor, and he was the son of
    a harlot; and Gilead begot Yiftach.”

    Abravanel’s questions on this chapter center on two subjects: Yiftach’s preliminary
    diplomatic talks with Ammon and Yiftach’s vow. In this essay, we’ll focus on the judge’s vow,
    one that he uttered on the eve of the Hebrews war with Ammon. It resulted when diplomacy
    failed.

    But, first, Abravanel looks at Yiftach, the ninth Hebrew judge, especially in the context of the
    family of origin’s dynamics. “Gilead begot Yiftach.” Even though the future judge’s mom was
    a slattern, the verse positively identifies Gilead as Yiftach’s dad. After Gilead’s dalliance with
    a trollop, he settled down and married. “And Gilead's wife bore him sons”. Abravanel deduces
    from the verses’ sequence that Yiftach was the oldest son. In time, his younger brothers
    schemed to banish him. “And when his wife's sons grew up, they drove out Yiftach, and said
    unto him: You shall not inherit in our father's house for you are the son of another woman.”
    Notwithstanding the younger brothers’ harsh words and deed, Jewish law, says Abravanel, begs
    to differ. That is, even though Yiftach was born of a harlot, and even though the marriage
    lacked proper chuppah and marriage contract, still and all, Yiftach was entitled to inherit
    from his father’s estate.

    But integrity didn’t seem to be the boys’ strong suit. They ousted their oldest brother. “Then
    Yiftach fled from his brethren” implies that he felt threatened. Strong-arm tactics forced
    Yiftach to run for his life. The next section of our chapter recounts how Ammon threatened
    Israel and as a result a contingency sought out Yiftach, in order to apologize and patch old
    hurts. Of course, the main motivation for making family peace was less than altruistic. The
    Hebrews felt Yiftach was the best man to restore peace in the region. After all, “Yiftach the
    Gileadite was a mighty man of valor.”

    As stated, Abravanel stresses the chapter’s concluding verses pertaining to Yiftach’s vow on
    the eve of hostilities with Ammon, and the aftermath of the battle. “And it came to pass after a
    while, that the children of Ammon made war against Israel…Then the spirit of the LORD came
    upon Yiftach, and he passed over Gilead and Manasseh, and passed over Mizpeh of Gilead,
    and from Mizpeh of Gilead he passed over unto the children of Ammon.”

    Prior to the surprise attack on Ammon, Yiftach made a compact with God. ”And Yiftach
    vowed a vow unto the LORD, and said: If You will indeed deliver the children of Ammon into my
    hand, then it shall be, that whatsoever comes forth of the doors of my house to meet me, when
    I return in peace from the children of Ammon, it shall be the LORD'S, and I will offer it up for a
    burnt-offering.”

    Yiftach’s war efforts against Ammon went swimmingly well. “So Yiftach passed over unto
    the children of Ammon to fight against them; and the LORD delivered them into his hand.”
    Après-guerre, a triumphant commander came home. “And Yiftach came to Mizpah unto his
    house, and, behold, his daughter came out to meet him with timbrels and with dances; and she
    was his only child; beside her he had neither son nor daughter.”

    Yiftach’s vow came back to haunt him. “And it came to pass, when he saw her, that he rent
    his clothes, and said: Alas, my daughter! you have brought me very low, and you have become
    my troubler; for I have opened my mouth unto the LORD, and I cannot go back.” Vows to God,
    of course, are serious business. What transpired next for Yiftach’s ill-starred daughter? Did he
    offer her on a sacrificial altar?

    Abravanel provides a straightforward approach. In fulfilment of his vow, Yiftach dedicated his
    daughter to the One Above. It means that he foreswore her to marry, or for that matter even to
    socialize. Instead, he moved her to a secluded house to live by herself, never to enjoy company,
    let alone get married. Secluded, she lived out the rest of her days. Only her friends would visit
    sparingly to speak with her from outside her abode, “to lament the daughter of Yiftach the
    Gileadite four days in a year.”

    Abravanel adds a titillating tidbit to the story. Namely, he puts forth that Christians took
    inspiration from Yiftach’s daughter’s deprivations, and modelled convents upon them. Nuns
    entered the cloister, a residence from which they lived out their days.

  • Judges 12 Judges of Israel: Yiftach (Jephthah), Ibzan, Elon, and Abdon

    Judges 12, a short chapter, writes fleetingly of three outstanding individuals who rose through the ranks
    to judge the Hebrews after Yiftach. We refer to Ibzan, Elon, and Abdon. Regarding them, Abravanel
    infuses his comments here with unusual observations or curios, especially for those interested in
    phonetics and sociology. However, the beginning of Judges 12 concludes a lengthy treatment of Yiftach.
    Recall, in Judges 11, we read about his military prowess, fearlessly leading his troops to handily defeat
    Ammon’s forces.

    “And the men of Ephraim were gathered together, and passed to Zaphon; and
    they said unto Yiftach: Wherefore did you pass over to fight against the children
    of Ammon, and did not call us to go with you? We will burn your house upon you
    with fire.”

    Victory should have been cause for his brethren’s appreciation, if not admiration. It wasn’t. Ephraim
    expressed only indignation at Yiftach, the Hebrew judge. “And the men of Ephraim were gathered
    together, and passed to Zaphon; and they said unto Yiftach: Wherefore did you pass over to fight
    against the children of Ammon, and did not call us to go with you? We will burn your house upon you
    with fire.”

    Measured criticism is one thing, Abravanel writes, threats to life and limb and property another. How
    ungrateful! Yiftach laid his life on the line to stop the enemy and secure the land of Israel. In that, he
    succeeded. What was Judge Yiftach’s answer to Ephraim’s contrived complaint?

    “And Yiftach said unto them: I and my people were at great strife with the children of Ammon; and
    when I called you, you saved me not out of their hand.” Yiftach and the Gileadites did not take kindly to
    Ephraim’s dire threats. At all. “And the Gileadites took the fords of the Jordan against the Ephraimites.
    And it was so, that when any of the fugitives of Ephraim said: Let me go over, the men of Gilead said
    unto him: Are you an Ephraimite? If he said: Nay; then said they unto him: Say now ‘Shibboleth' and he
    said “Sibboleth”; for he could not frame to pronounce it right; then they laid hold on him, and slew him
    at the fords of the Jordan; and there fell at that time of Ephraim forty and two thousand.” Abravanel
    teaches that Yiftach devised a phonetic test, to root out the evil men of Ephraim. Apparently, Abravanel
    gathers, owing to geological and/or climatological influence, the people of Ephraim lacked the ability to
    pronounce “Shibboleth”, and thus it came out as “Sibboleth.” Before moving on to the upcoming judge
    of Israel, Ibzan, Abravanel shares a historical observation about the French people back in his day
    (fifteenth century). That is, they too could not enunciate the “sh” sound. Instead, it came out as “s.”
    That concludes the chapter’s verses on Yiftach.

    “And after him Ibzan of Beth-lehem judged Israel. And he had thirty sons, and thirty daughters he sent
    abroad, and thirty daughters he brought in from abroad for his sons. And he judged Israel seven years.”
    Abravanel explains Ibzan’s conduct toward his sons and daughters when they reached a marriageable
    age. Namely, he sought husbands for his daughters from “abroad” or outside the region. After
    matrimony, Ibzan’s daughters remained with their husbands’ families. As for the judge’s sons, “and
    thirty daughters he brought in from abroad for his sons.” Put differently, Ibzan “imported” wives for the
    men.

    This custom of sending out daughters and bringing in daughters-in-laws was extant in Abravanel’s time
    as well. He cites the habit of the citizens of Genoa during the Renaissance period. (Abravanel died in
    Venice in 1508.). But, sociology aside, Abravanel asks: What’s the significance of these scant verses
    surrounding Ibzan, the tenth judge of Israel? The world, Abravanel waxes philosophical, is like a Ferris
    Wheel. Consider. Yiftach fathered only one child, a daughter. She hadn’t merited marriage. On account
    of Yiftach’s solemn vow, she separated herself from society; no man ever knew her. Ibzan’s family, on
    the other hand, grew greatly. “And he had thirty sons, and thirty daughters…”Through his merit, Ibzan
    lived to see all of his children married.

    In fantastic shorthand, Judges 12 concludes with nary a word about Elon and Abdon, respectively, the
    eleventh and twelfth judges of Israel.

  • Judges 13: Manoah’s Wife’s Angelic Visitor

    “And there was a certain man of Zorah, of the family of the Danites, whose
    name was Manoah; and his wife was barren, and bore not. And the angel of the
    LORD appeared unto the woman, and said unto her: Behold now, you are
    barren, and have not borne; but you shall conceive, and bear a son.”

    Bible commentators differ as to the nature of the Manoah’s wife’s visitor. Special he was, but was he an
    angel or a prophet? For Abravanel, actually, there wasn’t a question. Indeed, the visitor was non-
    corporeal, as we shall see. Furthermore, Abravanel addresses the question: What was the import of the
    extraordinary appearance to Manoah’s wife? That is, even if Samson’s conception and life mission
    would not have been foretold by an angel, so what? After all, the Maker is omnipotent. He could have
    promoted a Hebrew judge (Samson) from the rank and file, per se, to rally the Jews from the hands of
    the Philistines. Finally, Abravanel queries, even if the angel had not heralded the news that Samson
    would be a lifelong nazir, still and all, God could have inspired and appealed to Samson, directly, to
    pledge a nazarite vow later in life (and not from conception).

    From Judges 13, it seems that both Manoah and his wife fully assumed their herald was a man of God, a
    prophet, owing to his outward human garb. But the simple giveaway here is the language. “And the
    angel of the LORD appeared unto the woman.” Admittedly, Abravanel continues, sometimes in the
    Bible, prophets are called “angels of God.” Be that as it may, the principle is plain: “Angels of God” are,
    well, of the non-physical and totally intellect type.

    Returning back to Manoah and his wife, they supposed their visitor was a mortal, and thus offered him a
    meal. “And Manoah said unto the angel of the LORD: I pray you, let us detain you, that we may make
    ready a kid for you.”Of course, angels don’t eat, this one being no exception.

    Puzzled about the “prophet” standing before him, Manoah asked for his name. In ticks, Manoah began
    to process the true nature of his visitor. “And the angel of the LORD said unto him: Wherefore do you
    ask my name, seeing it is hidden?”The last clue cinched matters. “For it came to pass, when the flame
    went up toward heaven from off the altar, that the angel of the LORD ascended in the flame of the
    altar…”In a flash, the angel disappeared.

    In this manner, Abravanel demonstrates the true characterization of the couple’s caller. Hence, initially,
    Manoah and his wife believed their visitor to be a man of God. Ultimately, however, they came around
    and understood that a conversation with a wholly rational angel had transpired.

    What lay behind Heaven’s plan to communicate with Manoah’s wife, regarding the child she was soon
    to conceive? Here is Abravanel’s approach. At a most basic level, Samson’s mother would know that she
    would be expecting a highly-anticipated, miracle child. Most literally. When her son would be born and
    grow up, she would relate to the boy the wonder of his existence, the vital role for which he would be
    tasked. With this knowledge, Samson would, presumably, live up to his role as savior for his beleaguered
    brethren. Accordingly, he would conduct himself as the Creator’s conduit. With this awareness, the
    young man would develop and train himself for the mission, confident that God stood in his corner.

    Thus, Abravanel answers the questions posed above concerning the identity of the messenger, as well as
    why Heaven foretold the couple of Samson’s conception. In truth, Abravanel delves deeper into the
    subject, but we have shortened this essay in the interest of brevity.

  • Judges 14: Samson’s Philistine Wife

    On an enigma scale, if such a scale existed, Samson must rate as the most mercurial of all the
    Hebrew judges. In Judges 13 we read about the highly-anticipated – and angelic –
    foreshadowing of Samson’s conception and birth. Together with the announcement came
    instruction: Samson was to live all his days as a nazir.

    “And Samson went down to Timnah, and saw a woman in Timnah, of the daughters of the Philistines. And he came up, and told his father and his
    mother, and said: I have seen a woman in Timnah of the daughters of the
    Philistines; now therefore get her for me to wife.”

    Here in Judges 14, the Bible tracks Samson’s love life. And an outlandish one it was. “And
    Samson went down to Timnah, and saw a woman in Timnah of the daughters of the
    Philistines.” Besotted, the young Nazirite enlisted his parent’s help to make a match. “Now
    therefore get her for me a wife”, Samson begged.

    Mortified, Manoah and his wife recoiled. “Then his father and his mother said unto him: Is
    there never a woman among the daughters of your brethren, or among all my people, that you
    go to take a wife of the uncircumcised Philistines?”

    Mercilessly, Abravanel condemns Samson’s sexual mores. He charges: How could Samson,
    insofar as he had been designated by Above to judge the Jews, and insofar as he ascribed to a
    holy nazir’s lifestyle even before birth, and insofar as he foreswore any manner of spiritual
    defilement, how could he, to be blunt, fornicate with a foreign woman? And not any Gentile
    woman! The Philistine’s didn’t have the word moderation in their lexicon; the men libertine,
    the women wanton. In a word: Philistine society mired in smut.

    The Talmud tamps down Samson’s spouse selection. It says that Samson conditioned marriage
    on conversion, requiring his beloved to live as a Jewess. Abravanel demurs. The Book of Judges
    doesn’t mention anything of the sort, he explains. Moreover, the plain reading of Samson’s
    escapades with women, theirs with him, simply doesn’t conform to the Talmud’s position.

    Abravanel concludes his hard-hitting remarks. Samson’s malodorous lovers present Bible
    students with a predicament, as we have put forth. Aghast, we view with consternation the fact
    that a judge of the Hebrew nation would philander and cohort with Philistine women.

    In short form, here is Abravanel’s approach. To begin with, he says, it is not unusual for
    prophets to occasionally run afoul the strict letter of the law. This, the seers did, for the express
    purpose in fulfilling the service of God. One such example suffices here. Consider, Elijah. He
    offered a sacrifice atop a makeshift altar on Mount Carmel, in his contest against the priests of
    Baal. Strictly speaking, sacrifices may only be offered on the altar in Jerusalem’s Holy Temple.
    Still, Elijah took liberties as a “one off”, so that the Jews would reconnect with the Creator, as
    they chanted: “God is LORD.”

    Samson falls into the category of the Creator’s chosen ones whose lifestyle choices raise
    readers’ eyebrows and read, at least on the surface, distastefully. Yet, there was method to
    Samson’s madness, if you will. The judge’s Philistine consorts gave him entrée into the enemy
    camp. A Trojan horse.

    Samson’s gambit, or better, ruse would then accomplish the main thing – taking revenge on the
    Philistines for having wronged the Holy People. Furthermore, Abravanel argues that Samson’s
    unorthodox methodology differed from that of the earlier judges of Israel. Certainly, Samson
    was cut of a different cloth and thus divinely-inspired in ways that none of his predecessors had
    been. All the while, the God of Israel choreographed from Above, endowing Samson
    superhuman strength and pluck.

    As for Samson, he sincerely believed that his status as a nazir had not prohibited him from
    taking foreign women. Why? He only observed those Nazirite laws that had been explicitly
    conveyed by the heavenly messenger to his parents – no wine, haircut, and spiritual defilement.

  • Judges 15: Samson’s Revenge

    “But it came to pass after a while, in the time of wheat harvest, that Samson
    visited his wife with a kid[goat]; and he said: I will go in to my wife into the
    chamber. But her father would not suffer him to go in. And her father said: I
    verily thought that you had utterly hated her; therefore I gave her to your
    companion. Is not her younger sister fairer than she? take her, I pray you,
    instead of her.”

    To say that Samson and wife’s marriage stood on shaky ground from the get-go would be an
    understatement. No sooner had the couple spent their first week together than true-to-life
    drama unfolded. Essentially, the nuptials were ended before they began. Thus, the earlier
    chapter concludes: “But Samson's wife was given to his companion, whom he had had for his
    friend.”It was a bad split up, about to get worse.

    Samson had separated from his wife (Judges 14), but really hadn’t believed it was over. He
    sought to resume the relationship, although it had met strong headwinds. Reality set in for the
    lovestruck Samson when he returned home, only to be greeted by his father-in-law. He broke
    bad news. “But her father would not suffer him to go in. And her father said: I verily thought
    that you had utterly hated her; therefore I gave her to your companion.”

    The Hebrew judge fumed. “And Samson said unto them: This time shall I be quits with the
    Philistines, when I do them a mischief.” All concerned knew that Samson had been wronged by
    the Philistines. Taking away his beloved was the last straw. He pledged to even the score. Only
    after he got in the last licks, would he be ready to smoke the peace pipe with Philistines.

    And so Samson made his move. Using most unorthodox means, he set fire to Philistine’s fields.
    After an inquiry as to the cause of the conflagration, it was determined that Samson was the
    arsonist. It was further determined that Samson had been justified in taking the law into his
    own hands, on account of the wrong perpetrated to him when his wife was given to another
    man. In efforts to assuage an angry Samson, it was the locals turn to do popular justice. “And
    the Philistines came up, and burnt her and her father with fire.” That should have been the end
    of it.

    It wasn’t. “And Samson said unto them: If you do after this manner, surely I will be avenged of
    you, and after that I will cease.”That’s what Samson said. But his actions did not match his
    words. “And he smote them hip and thigh with a great slaughter; and he went down and dwelt
    in the cleft of the rock of Etam.” After killing a number of Philistines, he fled.

    For the Philistines, the short-fused Hebrew went too far. Samson’s fellow Jews concurred.
    Understanding their precarious and vulnerable socio-political situation, the Hebrews sought to
    capture Samson and extradite him to their masters, to the Philistines. They did. In chains,
    Samson was delivered.

    The Philistines shouted aloud when they saw Samson cuffed. Yet, they cheered prematurely. As
    our chapter relates, handcuffs proved no equal to Samson’s strength, and with God’s spirit
    upon the Hebrew judge, he handily slipped the chains off. That was only the beginning.

    “And he found a new jawbone of an ass, and put forth his hand, and took it, and smote a
    thousand men therewith.” Samson, alone, killed a thousand Philistines, oppressors of the
    Jewish people. Judges 15 concludes:” And he judged Israel in the days of the Philistines twenty
    years.”

    What, exactly, is going on here, asks Abravanel? Why didn’t Samson keep his side of the
    bargain, meaning that after the Philistines executed Samson’s father-in-law and wife, why
    didn’t that settle it? Moreover, Abravanel asks, how could Samson, a holy nazir and holy man to
    God, defile himself with the dead? With merely a primitive weapon (animal bone), he killed his
    enemy, rendering him spiritually defiled.

    On the first question, Abravanel shares a lesson in chivalry. Namely, when a man is wronged (as
    he was), there is no comfort in having others right the wrong. Especially in Samson’s case, since
    he was fully capable of meting out justice, the Philistines added insult to injury when they
    punished his despicable father-in-law and unfaithful wife. So, the Hebrew judge seethed.

    Abravanel explains that Samson did not break his word to desist from further acts of revenge.
    That is because the Philistines broke their promise by depriving Samson of avenging the affront.
    We proceed to answer Abravanel’s second question, concerning Samson’s spiritual defilement.

    True, spiritual defilement results when there is contact with the dead. Enter a dispensation:
    war. To the point, Jewish tradition holds that since Samson had not, on his own volition,
    accepted Nazirite vows, leniency availed itself to the Hebrew judge. As we read in Judges 13,
    the angel enlisted Samson into the ranks of the Nazarites. Narrowly, God’s agent spoke only to
    Samson’s restricted diet and ban on haircuts.

     

  • Judges 16: Samson’s Secret

    “And Samson went to Gaza, and saw there a harlot, and went in unto her. [And
    it was told] the Gazites, saying: Samson is come hither. And they compassed him
    in, and lay in wait for him all night in the gate of the city, and were quiet all the
    night, saying: Let be till morning light, then we will kill him.”

    Judges 16 concludes the story – and life – of Samson, the thirteenth and last Hebrew judge. Abravanel
    paints the man in complex hues. Very complex, as the lead verse above conveys. “And Samson went to
    Gaza, and saw there a harlot, and went into her.”Samson’s libido, Abravanel posits, was overcharged. At
    brothels, he was a regular. His last visit to Gaza’s red-light district proved his undoing. A fickle floozy
    betrayed him to the Philistines – for a pot of silver.

    In all fairness, Samson was much more than a womanizer. Indeed, his supernatural strength
    overwhelmed Philistines, mortal enemies of the Chosen People. As the Book of Judges states on two
    separate occasions: “And he judged Israel twenty years.”Why the repetition, Abravanel asks? His
    answer sheds light on this inscrutable individualist, cut from a different cloth.

    In Judges 15, we read: “Wherefore the name thereof was called En-hakkore, which is in Lehi unto this
    day. And he judged Israel in the days of the Philistines twenty years.” To provide context, Samson had
    massacred one thousand Philistines, a heartless foe that subjugated the Jews. After the killing spree,
    understandably enough, Samson was exhausted. Parched, he called out to God. God delivered a miracle,
    spring water. Of Samson’s piety, a verse makes it explicit. We focus on the verse’s proper noun: “En-
    hakkore.” It means beseeching the Maker. “And he judged Israel in the days of the Philistines twenty
    years.” Moving to our chapter, Judges 16, again we find the same information about Samson’s
    judgeship. “And he judged Israel twenty years.”

    What, Abravanel asks, is the reason behind the Book of Judges reiteration? For Abravanel, the key in
    understanding Samson focuses on one aspect of Jewish observance: compliance with Nazarite law. In
    Judges chapters 14 and 15, he toed the Nazarite line. As a result, the Creator lavished him with strength
    and valor. Judges 16 shows us a different and darker side. Accordingly, Judges 15, desiring to mark
    Samson’s moral decline (flouting Nazarite law), writes if you will, a eulogy, as if he died: “He judged
    Israel twenty years.”

    Yet, Samson didn’t truly die in Judges 15. In fact, he was very much alive – as an unfiltered Judges 16
    graphically depicts. Awash in testosterone, he slept with slatterns. One in particular caught his fancy.
    “And it came to pass afterward, that he loved a woman in the valley of Sorek, whose name was Delilah.”
    After Samson’s massacre of the Philistines (Judges 15), local chieftains put a bounty on his head. And a
    plan.

    They approached Delilah, Samson’s beloved, promising her a tidy sum of money, if she would betray her
    paramour. The plan called for Delilah to coax Samson into revealing the true source of his preternatural
    might. She would then exploit Samon’s secret and neutralize him, rendering him powerless. At that
    juncture, Philistines would pounce.

    Pounce they did. In a moment of weakness and vulnerability, Samson bared his heart and disclosed his
    secret weapon to Delilah. Sort of. “And he told her all his heart…There has not come a razor upon my
    head; for I have been a Nazirite unto God from my mother's womb. If I be shaven, then my strength will
    go from me, and I shall become weak, and be like any other man.”

    Hair, though, was not the source of Samson’s success; God was. When the judge’s conduct had been
    deemed meritorious, divine providence fortified him. Invincible – courtesy of Heaven’s miracles.
    However, when Samson strayed after his eyes, when he gave in to a galloping libido, providence packed
    up. Enervated.

    Sans help from Above, all looked bleak for Samson (and the downtrodden Hebrews). “The Philistines laid
    hold on him, and put out his eyes; and they brought him down to Gaza, and bound him with fetters of
    brass; and he did grind in the prison-house.”

    But, that’s not how the story – or Samson’s life – ends. While in captivity in Gaza, his hair, of course,
    began to grow. Still, Samson’s former turbo-strength stalled. As stated, being shaven or hirsute played
    no part in this Biblical script. Divine providence reinforced or removed, Samson’s prowess.

    Philistines praised their gods for having apprehended and imprisoned Samson. They also, as it turned
    out, celebrated prematurely. “And it came to pass, when their hearts were merry, that they said: Call for
    Samson, that he may make us sport. And they called for Samson out of the prison-house; and he made
    sport before them; and they set him between the pillars.” A blinded Samson was led into the jam-
    packed stadium to entertain the crowd.

    Above the din, a deeply contrite Samson returned to God, murmuring prayer in desperation. “And
    Samson called unto the LORD, and said: O Lord GOD, remember me, I pray You, and strengthen me, I
    pray You, only this once, O God, that I may be this once avenged of the Philistines for my two eyes.”

    But before uttering supplication to God, he spoke to the young guard who had escorted Samson from
    his cell. “And Samson said unto the lad that held him by the hand: Suffer me that I may feel the pillars
    whereupon the house rests, that I may lean upon them.” The ward complied.

    Samson stood positioned between two massive, support columns, touching both. “And Samson took
    fast hold of the two middle pillars upon which the house rested, and leaned upon them, the one with his
    right hand, and the other with his left.” To God he cried. “And Samson said: Let me die with the
    Philistines. And he bent with all his might; and the house fell upon the lords, and upon all the people
    that were therein. So the dead that he slew at his death were more than they that he slew in his life.”

    “Then his brethren and all the house of his father came down, and took him, and brought him up, and
    buried him between Zorah and Eshtaol in the burying-place of Manoah his father. And he judged Israel
    twenty years.” To the Philistines’ credit, Abravanel notes, they granted Samson a proper burial in Israel.
    They could have just as soon exhumed his body from the rubble and abused it.

    To return to Abravanel’s question about the reiteration of Samson’s judgeship, here is the upshot. After
    Samson ditched Nazarite laws, from a spiritual perspective, he died. Apropos, we read: “And he judged
    Israel in the days of the Philistines twenty years.” However, Judges 16 records his bodily death. Attesting
    to what had been his notable life achievement, it salutes the man who “judged Israel for twenty years.”

  • Judges 17: Micah’s Molten Image

    In a departure from the first sixteen chapters in the Book of Judges, the subject matter of the final five
    chapters does not speak about Hebrew leaders. In fact, it is the lack of leadership that underlies the
    religio-social catastrophes that get recorded in Judges. Societal collapse and a free-for-all are explicit: “In
    those days there was no king in Israel; every man did that which was right in his own eyes.”

    “Now there was a man of the hill-country of Ephraim, whose name was Micah.”

    Providing chronological context, Abravanel asserts that the narratives comprising the last chapters of
    Judges took place after Samson’s incarceration in Gaza. Timeline aside, let us shed light on this chapter’s
    main characters: Micah and his mother.

    “Now there was a man of the hill-country of Ephraim, whose name was Micah.” To be blunt, the man
    was a scoundrel. “And he said unto his mother: The eleven hundred pieces of silver that were taken
    from you, about which you did utter a curse, and did also speak it in my ears, behold, the silver is with
    me. I took it.”

    Readers will remember from the previous chapter that the number “eleven hundred” appeared. Delilah,
    Samson’s avaricious lover, betrayed him to the Philistine chieftains, all of whom pledged eleven hundred
    silver pieces for her perfidy. Returning to Micah, he “came clean”, confessing his crime to Mother and
    paid back in full.

    Abravanel explains that Micah desired to be a more dutiful son. He also couldn’t bear to hear any more
    of his mother’s cursing, for the shrew had been quite vocal about the robber, hexing him incessantly in
    earshot of her son. “The eleven hundred pieces of silver that were taken from you, about which you did
    utter a curse, and did also speak it in my ears…”

    Micah, Abravanel learns, deduced from his mother’s constant mouthing off whenever she saw him, that
    mom suspected Micah of the dirty deed. Dropping the charade, the son/thief “restored the eleven
    hundred pieces of silver to his mother…”

    What began as a weird, albeit thin, plot featuring an “inside job” thickens. “And his mother said: Blessed
    be my son of the LORD…and his mother said: I verily dedicate the sliver unto the LORD…to make…a
    molten image…”At this point, we’ve introduced a young man with sticky fingers and his foul-mouthed
    mom with a penchant for paganism. Lining the dots, we neatly trace a Hebrew society gone awry
    because “there was no king in Israel; every man did that which was right in his own eyes.” A nation
    adrift.

    Things worsened, Abravanel notes. Although Micah’s mother pledged 1100 pieces of silver to forge a
    molten image, she reneged. “His mother took two hundred pieces of silver, and gave them to the
    founder…who made thereof a graven image and a molten image…” What started as a vow to donate
    eleven hundred silver pieces ended as gift of two hundred. Honest, mom wasn’t.

    She was, however, interested in advancing her son’s (dubious) career as a pagan priest. The molten
    image was located “in the house of Micah.” Micah set his sights higher for this, to be facetious, house of
    worship. “And the man Micah had a house of God, and he made an ephod, and teraphim, and
    consecrated one of his sons, who became his priest.”Quite the family affair.

    Quite the chaos too. “In those days there was no king in Israel…” To elaborate and review, here’s what
    Abravanel shares.

    • Micah steals mom’s money
    • Micah restores the money
    • Mom receives the money, asks Micah to hire a silversmith
    • Micah refuses and insists mom herself hires a silversmith
    • Mom commissions a molten image
    • Micah decks out his house of God with the molten image, ephod, and teraphim

    Commentators differ as to Micah’s level of spirituality. Abravanel quotes one of them who believes that
    Micah began as a soul searcher. For him, the phrase “And the man Micah had a house of God” implies a
    spiritual retreat, a place where he could meditate and commune with his Creator. This quiet corner, to
    be upfront, housed a molten image, but that wasn’t to pray to. Its purpose was to create the right
    ambiance, so that a more intimate relationship with God could be established.

    Be that as it may, this much cannot be denied. Though Micah’s mom furnished the house of worship
    with the molten image, Micah embellished the temple by adding accoutrements like an ephod and
    teraphim. Beefing up his operation, he also hired one of his sons to officiate as a priest.

    Of course, readers will find this passage terribly odd. The upcoming verse gives perspective. “In those
    days there was no king in Israel; every man did that which was right in his own eyes.” Why hadn’t
    someone spoken up at the insidious, idolatrous idiocy? Why hadn’t authorities arrested offenders? Was
    there no outcry, let alone indignation?

    To all those questions, one answer suffices. Anarchy reigned. In the absence of an authority, a judge, a
    king, or an officer the Hebrews, pitifully, did whatever they darned pleased.

  • Judges 18 Micah’s Molten Image: Epilogue

    “In those days there was no king in Israel; and in those days the tribe of the
    Danites sought them an inheritance to dwell in; for unto that day there had
    nothing been allotted unto them among the tribes of Israel for an inheritance.”

    Judges 18 depicts the holy nation’s continued sharp moral decline, a skid that began in Judges
    17 with the manufacture of and homage to Micah’s molten image. As for the rationale behind
    their unconscionable conduct, it wasn’t hard to figure out: “In those days there was no king in
    Israel…”What is harder to figure out is this chapter’s storyline. Abravanel smooths over the
    rough patches, some of which are addressed presently.

    •  Why does the verse teach that Danites hadn’t been allotted an inheritance in the Holy
      Land? Patently false. Joshua 19 writes explicitly: “The seventh lot came out for the tribe
      of the Children of Dan… And the border of their inheritance was Zorah, and Eshtaol, and
      Ir-shemesh…”
    •  Furthermore, no less than three times in our chapter, we read that the Danites stole
      Micah’s molten images. Why rehash it?

    Following are Abravanel’s answers, albeit in shorthand. Of course, Danites had been allocated a
    portion of the Holy Land, no differently than the other tribes. Still, Danites desired a bigger
    chunk. In efforts to expand, they spied out places with potential. According to Abravanel, they
    followed Moses’ playbook. That is, just as Moses had sent out twelve spies, corresponding to
    the twelve tribes, so too Danites. That particular tribe comprised five families or clans, thus that
    number of sleuths set out on a secret mission. As for a motivation to expand, Abravanel posits
    that their portion left them isolated, and so they wanted to occupy territory that allowed them
    greater security. Still and all, the Danites’ conduct as depicted in our chapter cannot be
    condoned. More preferable options availed themselves, however “in those days there was no
    king in Israel”and Danites soiled their reputation by their adventurism and impetuosity.

    When the Danites pilfered Micah’s molten images, an event thrice-repeated here, red lights
    flashed, so heinous was the wrongdoing. Abravanel offers this. En route to conquer new lands,
    Danite troops – six hundred to be precise – took a detour. “And the six hundred men girt with
    their weapons of war, who were of the Children of Dan, stood by the entrance of the gate. And
    the five men that went to spy out the land went up, and came in thither, and took the graven
    image, and the ephod, and the teraphim, and the molten image; and the priest stood by the
    entrance of the gate with the six hundred men girt with weapons of war.”

    What were Danites possibly thinking? One thing is certain. As bad as their deed had been, they
    had not stooped so low as to attribute inherent, divine power to Micah’s tinny trinkets. Instead,
    Danites believed that when Micah’s molten image was patched together, it somehow inspired
    the practicing or participating priest to use it for purposes of harnessing divine intervention,
    rendering it an intermediary. The future, then, could be determined in advance. Just to be clear,
    Danites believed that God, through a middleman and molten image, would disclose tomorrow’s
    events.

     

  • Judges 19 Concubine in Gibeah: Foul Play

    “And it came to pass in those days, when there was no king in Israel, that there
    was a certain Levite sojourning on the farther side of the hill-country of Ephraim,
    who took to him a concubine out of Beth-lehem in Judah.”

    If Judges 19 sounds like déjà vu, it’s no accident. After all, the last few chapters have been
    hammering away at the underlying problem: Hebrews acted horribly because “there was no
    king in Israel.”According to Abravanel, recall, there was a judge and his name was Samson.
    However, he was not in Israel. Philistines entrapped him, shackled him, and brought him to
    Gaza. In his absence, and with nobody else to step up, these concluding chapters in Judges tell
    the sorry saga of a sidetracked nation.

    Beside the common refrain of an unmoored society, Abravanel identifies additional links
    between these chapters. Venue is one common denominator – “the farther side of the hill-
    country of Ephraim.”Another common location is Beth-lehem. Turning from places to people,
    the previous chapter and our chapter feature Levites. Tragedy struck for the Jews, also, on
    account of women. In Judges 18, Micah’s mom, a true termagant contributed not a little to
    national morass; whereas in Judges 19 we read about internecine fighting as a result of the
    Levite’s concubine.

    Here is another observation by Abravanel. These chapters highlight a total religio/societal
    freefall. Namely, Micah and mother flouted Torah law by openly introducing a molten image in
    religious rites. Thereby, Hebrews faltered in a spiritual sense. Contrast that to our chapter. It
    stresses something else: physical destruction. That is because our chapter’s imbroglio
    fomented civil war, pitting the tribe of Benjamin against the other tribes. But let us not jump
    ahead, as far as storyline here is concerned.

    Abravanel’s comments allow for a methodical interpretation of the cataclysmic occurrences
    that triggered a conflagration in Israel, as the Book of Judges comes to its fiery close. Let us first
    establish the facts and then we shall see how Abravanel infuses novel insights. Note, that while
    the ultimate cause of these chapters has to do with a dearth of leadership, there are substrata
    at play.

    “And it came to pass in those days, when there was no king in Israel, that there was a certain
    Levite sojourning on the farther side of the hill-country of Ephraim, who took to him a
    concubine out of Beth-lehem in Judah.” Concubines are, for our purposes, wives. “And his
    concubine played the harlot against him, and went away from him unto her father’s house to
    Beth-lehem in Judah, and was there for a space of four months.”Actually, in the Bible, “Playing
    the harlot” is more innocuous than it sounds. She hadn’t been unfaithful to her Levite husband.
    She had, though, walked out on him.

    Time elapsed. “Four months” to be precise. The Levite and his attendant went to the
    concubine’s father’s house to accompany her home to the hill-country. After spending several
    days with his father-in-law, a gracious host who found it difficult to part with the traveling
    party, the couple made their way to the hill-country of Ephraim. The visit and the warm
    dialogue between the Levite and his wife’s father are recorded in our chapter. On the road to
    the hill-country of Ephraim, trouble lurked.

    Intending to enter a Jewish-populated city to spend the night (and bypass Gentile-ruled Jebus),
    the travelers reached Gibeah. It was situated within Benjamin’s territory. A nightmare out of
    the Book of Genesis awaited. We refer to the story of Lot, Abraham’s nephew who dwelled in
    the cruel environs of Sodom and Gomorrah.

    In journalistic fashion, we record the bald facts of the crime and its aftermath.

    • A kind, old man came in from the fields in the evening. He took pity on the out-of-
      towners, inviting them to stay the night.
    • At nightfall, local rowdies pounded on the door and surrounded the host’s house. They
      threatened the old man, insisting they send out the Levite to sodomize him.

    Abravanel interjects that the ruffians were not homosexuals. Had that been their sexual
    orientation, they would have demanded the Levite and his male attendant. It is likely, then, that
    their initial demand for the Levite guest was merely a ruse. Probably, word spread quickly that
    visitors were staying with the old man. Among them was a gorgeous and voluptuous woman.
    Vile scumbags desired her (not her husband). Back to the facts in Gibeah.

    • Reminiscent of Lot’s gambit (See Genesis 19.), the host ignobly offered the howling
      sickos his own daughter and the Levite’s concubine, setting the unconscionable stage,
      albeit with a twist. The host pushed out the concubine, while sparing his daughter.
    • After gang rape, perpetrators sent their victim out. The concubine staggered back to the
      old man’s house. Outside the front door, she collapsed.
    • In the morning, the Levite opened the front door to leave. He found his wife barely
      alive. Picking her up and placing her on the pack animal, the Levite headed home to the
      hill-country.
    • Along the way, the concubine succumbed and died.
    • Then, the Levite dismembered wife’s lifeless body, distributing pieces to all the tribes.

    Abravanel scrutinizes the unconscionable sequence of circumstances, in what goes down as one
    of the Bible’s most deranged deeds. But that’s for Bible Seascapes, an Abravanel Anthology, to be published in 2026.

  • Judges 2: Angel of God’s Speech

    “And the angel of the LORD came up from Gilgal to Bochim. And he said: I made
    you to go up out of Egypt, and have brought you unto the land which I swore
    unto your fathers. And I said: I will never break My covenant with you.”

    Abravanel follows ancient Jewish predecessors to explain the identity of our verse’s “angel of
    God.”Either the angel was a man who had received prophecy from the Maker or possibly, the
    angel was Phineas. Either way, the angel heard God’s word in Gilgal. He then left Gilgal and
    went to a place called Bochim. In Hebrew it means to cry or weep. Abravanel continues. The
    place had another name (though we don’t know what) and only later, after the Hebrews heard
    the angel’s words and internalized the fraught message that brought people to tears, did the
    place get its new name – Bochim.

    The angel of God commenced his speech. “And he said: I made you go up out of Egypt, and
    have brought you unto the land which I swore unto your fathers…”What was the angel driving
    at with his rousing words? What did he want to impart at this very historic juncture, so shortly
    after Joshua’s death?

    Chilling words they were. “And I said: I will never break My covenant with you.” Explanation, or
    better qualification followed, according to Abravanel. The angel taught the Children of Israel
    that the Creator hadn’t budged, nor would He ever budge from His affection for His people.

    Here’s the thing about God’s love for His people, evidenced by divine covenant with the nation.
    It’s conditional. “And you shall make no covenant with the inhabitants of this land. You shall
    break down their altars. But you have not hearkened unto My voice. What is this you have
    done?”God made matters crystal clear. If the Jews desired to commit themselves to the
    covenant with the Maker, then the nation would not be at liberty to sign side agreements with
    Canaanites, seeing that they are God’s enemies.

    Abravanel simplifies matters. Whereas, God is the One Who brought the Jews out of Egypt, and
    whereas, He is their Master and Ruler, it would be the height of chutzpah and injudicious
    conduct to go behind the Master’s back for purposes of consummating a compact with the
    Master’s foes. It just isn’t done.

    Yet, the Jews did precisely that. They had not driven out the Canaanites from the Holy Land.
    Worse still, the Jews entered into agreements with the pagans. “But you have not hearkened
    unto My voice. What is this you have done?”

    God said more. “Wherefore I also said: I will not drive them out from before you. But they shall
    be unto you as snares, and their gods shall be a trap unto you.” Since the Jews made their bed,
    so to speak, they would face the consequences of their infidelity to God. “I will not drive them
    out…”Of course, the Maker knew exactly what would transpire: “They shall be unto you as
    snares, and their gods shall be a trap…”

    Abravanel concludes his remarks. The reason why God communicated this message at this
    juncture had to do with the facts on the ground after Joshua’s death. The tribes had been lax in
    ousting Canaanite pockets within their respective territories, as we read in Judges 1. Hence,
    God’s words serve as a rebuke and warning for not having expelled Canaanites from Israel.

    The Jews reaction came quickly. “And it came to pass, when the angel of the LORD spoke these
    words unto all the Children of Israel, that the people lifted up their voice, and wept. And they
    called the name of that place Bochim; and they sacrificed there unto the LORD.”

  • Judges 20: Civil War

    “Then all the Children of Israel went out, and the congregation was assembled
    as one man, from Dan even to Beer-sheba, with the land of Gilead, unto the
    LORD at Mizpah."

    War drums droned. Civil war loomed. Judges 20 records the bloody battles that claimed the
    lives of tens of thousands of Hebrews. Seeds of disaccord, however, had been steadily sowed
    and nursed over the past several chapters. The Jews had become a rudderless nation, morally
    bankrupt. Samson, the Hebrew judge who, in theory, could have provided an ample antidote to
    anarchy and shore up ethical decline and unrest, had been put out of commission. In a
    Philistine prison, his eyes gouged out, he languished.

    But what was the civil war’s casus belli? Judges 19 highlighted the abduction and rape of the
    Levite’s concubine in Gibeah. It left a young married woman dead and her Levite husband
    inconsolable. Frightfully, that fueled flames.

    Abravanel thoroughly analyzes this chapter’s internecine conflict. For our purposes here, we
    focus on one aspect of his essay: Were the tribes, collectively, rash when they gathered
    together to declare war on the tribe of Benjamin? “Then all the Children of Israel went out, and
    the congregation was assembled as one man…And the chiefs of all the people, even of all the
    tribes of Israel…”

    Shouldn’t the tribes first have fully gathered all relevant material facts and ascertained the
    circumstances, before taking the offensive? Why hadn’t tribal heads traveled to the crime
    scene (hill-country, Ephraim), rounded up suspects, and questioned witnesses and top brass? If
    Benjamin’s officials would have failed to cooperate, let alone had they outright rebuffed the all-
    tribe contingent, other avenues could have been explored – keeping all options on the table.
    Abravanel fills in the blanks, regarding this rock-bottom episode in Jewish history.

    To compound matters, Abravanel continues, see the Book of Joshua 22. There we read how
    some of the tribes (Reuben and Gad) seemed to contravene Torah law, to the chagrin of Joshua
    and the other tribes. Judiciously, Joshua convened those tribal heads accused of wrongdoing.
    When the accused explained their actions, and when Joshua had been convinced of their
    innocence, tensions immediately resided. Peaceful coexistence between all twelve tribes
    resumed. Why, then, hadn’t the tribes here acted reasonably toward Benjamin’s tribe?

    Instead, ostensibly, they flouted due process. “And the chiefs…presented themselves of the
    people of God, four hundred thousand footmen that drew sword.” In the presence of the tribes
    in Mizpah, the widower’s testimony was heard. “Now the Children of Benjamin heard that the
    Children of Israel were gone up to Mizpah. And the Children of Israel said: Tell us, how was the
    wickedness brought to pass? And the Levite, the husband of the woman who was murdered
    answered and said…”

    Before the all-tribe tribunal, the Levite introduced new facts. “I came into Gibeah that belongs
    to Benjamin, I and my concubine, to lodge.” Next followed lurid information. “And the men of
    Gibeah rose up against me, and beset the house round about me by night. Me they thought to
    kill, and my concubine they forced. And she is dead.”Note, this chapter fills in details that had
    not been conveyed in the previous chapter. Abravanel adds that the Levite, if he would have
    been handed over to the men demanding to rape him, would have made sure that didn’t
    happen, preferring death. Thus, “they thought to kill me…”

    Here is Abravanel’s approach. He believes that two separate conventions took place. One
    comprised eleven tribes in Mizpah sans Benjamin; the other one convened in Benjamin,
    attended only by that tribe’s head council. Specifically, just as soon as Benjaminites learned of
    their brethren’s gathering in Mizpah, they reacted in kind – calling a separate gathering in their
    territory. Feeling threatened, Benjaminites prepared their self-defense.

    To recap, in Mizpah, the eleven-tribe tribunal subpoenaed the Levite. He gave testimony of that
    day’s events in Gibeah. Salient facts emerged from the hearing. The Levite testified as to the
    bodily threat he faced. Moreover, the magistrates heard about the gang rape that left the
    concubine critically injured. By the morning, she succumbed to her wounds. The Levite
    admitted that he, not the rapists, carved up the dead woman’s body, dispatching body parts
    throughout the land. Why? The Levite believed the assault was of national importance, and not
    a matter for the Benjamin police. In essence, he argued that, in principle, he acknowledged,
    each tribe had the requisite authority to adjudicate (in legal/moral problems). However, the
    Levite asserted, his case warranted national attention and a collective resolution, because it
    involved extreme moral turpitude. Besides, the Levite concluded his remarks, each Jew is
    bound to and responsible for each other’s conduct.

    Did the Hebrews want to deter depravity, or look the other way and join the ranks of Sodom
    and Gomorrah? The short answer is “no.” Due process had been meticulously observed.

  • Judges 21: Jabesh-Gilead, The Holdouts

    “And the Children of Israel said: Who is there among all the tribes of Israel that
    came not up in the assembly unto the LORD? For they had made a great oath
    concerning him that came not up unto the LORD to Mizpah, saying: He shall
    surely be put to death.”

    Judges 20 covered the Civil War, one that pitted the tribe of Benjamin against all of the other
    eleven tribes of Israel combined. Before that catastrophic and bloody war, certain things
    transpired, as Abravanel explains here in Judges 21. That is, even though our chapter follows
    Judges 20, nevertheless, chronologically speaking, things recorded here relate to it and
    supplement it.

    Recall, we learned in Judges 20 that the eleven tribes sought to diffuse the bad blood between
    Benjamin and his brethren on the heels of the Concubine from Gibeah Affair. “And the tribes of
    Israel sent men through all the tribe of Benjamin, saying: What wickedness is this that is come
    to pass among you? Now therefore deliver up the men, the base fellows that are in Gibeah,
    that we may put them to death…”Had Benjamin delivered the culprits to the Children of Israel,
    normal relations between all twelve tribes could have restored. But they didn’t and it hadn’t.
    Consequently, Judges 20 chronicles the internecine battles that ripped a nation asunder.

    Here, we share one aspect of Abravanel’s comments on Judges 21: Jabesh-Gilead (belonging to
    the tribe of Manasseh). On the eve of the war to punish Benjamin for gross malfeasance, Israeli
    leadership called for full military mobilization. Every tribe was to participate – on penalty of
    death for dereliction of duty. “And the Children of Israel said…concerning him that came not up
    unto the LORD in Mizpah, saying: He shall surely be put to death.”

    Notwithstanding the obvious importance of equitably shouldering military duties, Abravanel
    asks here: Why did the Hebrew top brass issue death warrants for those eligible men who failed
    to appear at the conscription headquarters in Mizpah?

    After a full-blown investigation into the identity of the draft dodgers, the Children of Israel
    tracked down Jabesh-Gilead. They had sat out the war with Benjamin. Herculean efforts to
    ascertain the holdouts bespeaks a truism: Hebrews place great stress on and took great pains to
    keep their oaths – “for they had made a great oath concerning him that came not up unto the
    LORD to Mizpah…”

    Abravanel unpacks this passage. Note, he writes, the verse says “unto the LORD to Mizpah”and
    it doesn’t say “to fight against Gibeah.” The import, Abravanel suggests, is this. The convocation
    in Mizpah was, essentially, a religious one. Jewish leaders called for the people to ascend to
    Mizpah for purposes of self-introspection – “unto the LORD to Mizpah.” However, had the
    reason behind the gathering to do with military mobilization, the verse would have said: “to
    fight against Gibeah.” But that was not the wording.

    Abravanel continues. If, in fact, the convention had been to procure troops for war, then it
    would not have been so strange that some men shied away. That is because some men are
    cowardly. They hide rather than appear before a draft board. Yet, that was not the case here.
    Men turned their back “unto the LORD to Mizpah.” Such conduct cannot be condoned. Hence it
    aroused the Jewish leadership’s ire. Absence amounted to a religious affront.

    We circle back and address Abravanel’s question posed above: Why was it paramount in the
    minds of the Hebrew leaders to seek out and ostracize Jabesh-Gilead after the civil war
    concluded? For brevity, we bring here the first of the four rationales that Abravanel provides.

    It is crucial to understand the mechanics of Biblical oaths and vows. The Hebrew tribunal
    operated under the assumption that the oath had been uttered in public (“For they had made a
    great oath concerning him that came not up unto the LORD to Mizpah, saying: He shall surely
    be put to death.”)It means that public oaths, in contrast to private or personal oaths, don’t have
    escape clauses. Enter one more key factor: There was no king in Israel. Had there been a
    national leader, that king or judge would have been capable of pronouncing a vow as a national
    obligation, as well as authorized to retract or void it. Abravanel puts in one more piece. It is
    that, in theory, a similarly-sized convention could have abrogated the oath, an oath that had
    been pronounced before the war with Benjamin. But, after the war, and after tens of thousands
    of war casualties, the next public gatherings, perforce, would not have matched the magnitude
    of participants when compared to before the war. Bottom line: Hebrew leaders felt the oath
    could not be rescinded.

  • Judges 3: Judge of Israel: Othniel Son of Kenaz

    According to Abravanel, the first two chapters in Judges act as an introduction: they set the
    tone for the balance of the book, where noticeable patterns emerge. Hebrews blunder (read:
    worship Canaanite gods); God exacts punishment; chastened Jews cry out to Him, begging for
    respite; the Maker sends relief, in the form of judges.

    “Now these are the nations which the LORD left, to prove Israel by them, even as
    many as had not known all the wars of Canaan; namely, the five lords of the
    Philistines…”

    After Joshua died, it wasn’t long in coming before Hebrews succumbed to foreign temptation,
    in a grotesque show of ethical-impairment. This, in turn, triggered trouble from Above. The first
    man sent by God to turn the tide, save them, and judge Israel was Othniel son of Kenaz, hailing
    from the tribe of Judah.

    Now let us see how Judges 3 conforms to the template mentioned above. “And the Children of
    Israel did that which was evil in the sight of the LORD, and forgot the LORD their God, and
    served the Baalim and the Asheroth. Therefore, the anger of the LORD was kindled against
    Israel, and He gave them over into the hand of Cushan-rishathaim king of Aram-naharaim. And
    the Children of Israel served Cushan-rishathaim eight years.”

    Religious reevaluation ensued. “And when the Children of Israel cried unto the LORD, the LORD
    raised up a savior to the Children of Israel, who saved them, even Othniel the son of Kenaz,
    Caleb's younger brother.”Note, Abravanel writes, how the overall pattern fills in particulars.
    That is, what had the Hebrews done to provoke God? Whom had the Maker chosen
    (emboldened Gentile ruler) to bring to heel the backsliding nation? Early on in our chapter we
    find cause: “And the Children of Israel dwelt among the Canaanites, the Hittites, and the
    Amorites, and the Perizzites, and the Hivites, and the Jebusites. And they took their daughters
    to be their wives, and gave their own daughters to their sons, and served their gods.” Patently,
    the people were awash in morass.

    Next, Heaven identified a useful agent (read: enemy) through whom to settle His score with a
    wanton nation virtually empty of Sinai’s ethos. “Therefore the anger of the LORD was kindled
    against Israel, and He gave them over into the hand of Cushan-rishathaim king of Aram-
    naharaim; and the Children of Israel served Cushan-rishathaim eight years.” The overlord’s
    name, Cushan-rishathaim, bespoke his character: he was a rat.

    At that low juncture, eight years of torment under the monster Cushan-rishathaim, the Jews
    had a change of heart. “And when the Children of Israel cried unto the LORD, the LORD raised
    up a savior to the Children of Israel, who saved them, even Othniel the son of Kenaz, Caleb's
    younger brother. And the spirit of the LORD came upon him, and he judged Israel; and he went
    out to war, and the LORD delivered Cushan-rishathaim king of Aram into his hand. And his hand
    prevailed against Cushan-rishathaim.”

    Abravanel, in agreement with earlier commentators, explains the meaning of the words, “the
    spirit of the LORD came upon him.” High-level communiques from God arrive to man in two
    distinct ways. The highest or purest form of communication refers to prophecy. A tad lower is
    when God’s spirit enters someone. Essentially that tier of divine talk boils down to an extremely
    high degree of heavenly inspiration. The recipient of “the spirit of the LORD” becomes wholly
    focused and fearless – unstoppable.

    Indeed, he’s a man imbued with a mission. Specifically, his determination and valor stir in his
    breast and will not rest until he rescues worthy people out of the hand of thugs. Stress and
    underscore: the inspired leader in our chapter is Othniel, a man turbo-charged by the One
    Above.

    Abravanel adds another point about judges. It is that they performed two vital religio/societal
    functions. One is that they literally sat in judgement, as in adjudication between litigants. Two,
    they led the troops. And on that second point, we’re not talking about a single military
    campaign. Oftentimes in Judges, we speak about ongoing wars. Thus, this chapter’s section
    sums up and concludes Othniel’s deserved place in history: “And the land had rest forty years.
    And Othniel the son of Kenaz died.”

    Before we move onto Judges 4, the remainder of the verses in this chapter record more of the
    classic pattern we highlighted above. Thus, shortly after Othniel passed, the nation floundered,
    as far as religious compliance was concerned. After sinning, and after receiving their just
    deserts, and after expressing contrition to the Creator, the Hebrews would be saved – first by
    Ehud son of Gera the Benjamite and then next by Shamgar son of Anath.

  • Judges 4: Deborah The Prophetess and Barak

    “And the Children of Israel again did that which was evil in the sight of the
    LORD, when Ehud was dead. And the LORD gave them over into the hand of
    Jabin king of Canaan, that reigned in Hazor; the captain of whose host was
    Sisera, who dwelt in Harosheth-goiim.”

    The main thrust of Judges 4 features Deborah the prophetess. Our chapter begins by
    chronicling Deborah’s predecessors. Well, sort of. Shamgar son of Anath (See the end of Judges
    3.) really was the judge before Deborah’s ascendancy; whereas Ehud son of Gera preceded
    Shamgar. Abravanel explains our verse’s seemingly sloppy history lesson. Briefly, he holds that
    “the Children of Israel again did that which was evil in the sight of the LORD when Ehud was
    dead”to mean that national misconduct followed Ehud’s passing. Thus, when Shamgar judged
    the nation after Ehud, Hebrews were already in sharp moral decline. As for Shamgar’s influence
    or salvation, it had only been minor, a band aid at best.

    Consequently, by the time Deborah the prophetess took center stage, her co-religionists had hit
    rock bottom, in terms of flouting Torah rules. For the Chosen People, things looked beyond
    bleak. King Jabin and his polished army gave the Jews no quarter. “And the Children of Israel
    cried unto the LORD; for he had nine hundred chariots of iron; and twenty years he mightily
    oppressed the Children of Israel. Now Deborah, a prophetess, the wife of Lapidoth, she judged
    Israel at that time.”

    Because of the scant textual description of Deborah, Abravanel supplies more information.
    Though the verse writes explicitly that Deborah was a prophetess, this requires explanation in
    light of the upcoming verses. But first, we read about her holding court: “And she sat under the
    palm-tree of Deborah between Ramah and Beth-el in the hill-country of Ephraim; and the
    Children of Israel came up to her for judgment.” Clearly, she acted as a magistrate. But then,
    Abravanel notes, things get strange.

    Deborah prepared to fight King Jabin. “And she sent and called Barak the son of Abinoam out of
    Kedesh-naphtali, and said unto him: Has not the LORD, the God of Israel, commanded, saying:
    Go and draw toward mount Tabor, and take with you ten thousand men of the Children of
    Naphtali and of the Children of Zebulun? And I will draw unto you to the brook Kishon Sisera,
    the captain of Jabin's army, with his chariots and his multitude; and I will deliver him into your
    hand.”Deborah’s war strategy is outlined.

    Yet, Abravanel asks, if indeed Deborah achieved prophecy, providing her with a fail-safe plan to
    overthrow King Jabin, why did Barak balk? “And Barak said unto her: If you will go with me,
    then I will go; but if you will not go with me, I will not go.”Hadn’t the God of Israel commanded,
    as quoted above? If so, why did Barak refuse? Why did he condition taking the field on
    Deborah’s participation? Bucking God’s order and His prophet (Deborah) rate an egregious
    crime, for which the Torah metes out capital punishment (Deuteronomy 18).

    Basing himself on our text here, Abravanel teaches us about Deborah. She certainly received
    communiqués from Above. That bespeaks intellectual brilliance, not to mention her prophetic
    preparedness. In time, the Maker granted her entrée into His confidence, per se, and spoke to
    her. Next, Abravanel explains another description of the prophetess: “the wife of Lapidoth.”
    This phrase does not record her marital status. Instead, it shares more about the woman: she
    was a powerhouse. Possessing a stout and unflinching heart, Deborah got things done – in
    lightning speed. “Lapidoth” in Hebrew means lightning bolt. How apt is this portrayal of her, a
    woman who assessed matters and took charge.

    Indeed, Deborah was no non-sense. With personality traits detailed above, she sat in
    judgement, chastised her fellow Jews to redouble religious observance, and understood the art
    of warfare. Abravanel returns to the question posed above: Given all these abilities and
    national achievements, how did Barak doubt her prophecy that spelled out the winning war
    plan against King Jabin?

    God instructed Deborah to enlist Barak’s assistance, as stated above. For his part, Barak was
    singled out, a testimony to his own sterling character, let alone his fearlessness in the face of
    danger. This, Abravanel deduces from his name: Barak son of Abinoam. “Barak” conveys
    boundless energy, really the same vibe as Deborah, to be colloquial. From the name
    “Abinoam”, we learn that Barak hailed from good stock. Just as his father was pleasant and
    warm, so too did Barak share those personable traits.

    So, what gave Barak pause in fulfilling Deborah’s message from God? Hadn’t victory been
    assured by Him? The problem, Abravanel learns, was not with Barak. It was with his troops.
    Fearful and intimidated by King Jabin and Sisera’s fighters, the Jews lost heart. After all, nine
    hundred chariots of iron were not a trifling threat. Thus, when Barak contemplated contending
    with Jabin and Sisera, he understood that he would not be able to rally his troops. That is,
    unless, Deborah joined forces with them. To the point, the Jews would not believe Deborah’s
    prophecy unless she herself participated in the war. Hence, Barak believed in Deborah’s
    prophecy, but in order to rally sagging esprit de corps, he needed Deborah’s presence.

    In sum, Abravanel posits that Deborah would either instill confidence and courage in the hearts
    of the Hebrews, or possibly her participation would harness divine providence. Either way,
    Barak insisted that the prophetess make an appearance.

  • Judges 5: Deborah’s Song

    “Then sang Deborah and Barak the son of Abinoam on that day, saying…”

    Truly exalted poetry aptly describes Deborah’s divinely-inspired song. By no means is the Bible
    (or post-Biblical times) a stranger to divine poetry or song, as Abravanel writes extensively in
    Exodus 15 (See Abravanel’s World.). But even a quick glimpse shows depth and insight. At
    heart, the poem reads as a paean to the Maker, for having delivered the Jews from their
    enemies’ clutches. “And the hand of the Children of Israel prevailed more and more against
    Jabin the king of Canaan, until they had destroyed Jabin king of Canaan. Then sang Deborah and
    Barak the son of Abinoam on that day, saying…”

    Deborah the prophetess penned her song for the ages. Beside the religious overtone
    reverberating throughout the stanzas, It’s also replete with a frank assessment of her
    countrymen. We shall see how Deborah sang the praises of some tribes, for their valor and
    altruism, while of other tribes she painted disparaging hues. We’ll focus on Abravanel’s
    comments on a segment of Deborah’s song.

    “The kings came, they fought; then fought the kings of Canaan, in Taanach by the waters of
    Megiddo; they took no gain of money.” Abravanel explains that the Hebrew tribes did not want
    to lend a hand in the holy cause, in God’s war. Contrast that attitude of laissez-faire, per se,
    with that of the Gentile leaders. “The kings came, they fought…” Volunteerism, for the
    Hebrews’ enemies, was off the charts; they came in droves.

    They also came for free. “They took no gain of money.” Though soldiers of fortune could have
    extracted handsome sums for their efforts, they didn’t ask King Jabin for a farthing. Money was
    the last thing on their minds. If Hebrew enemies came to fight the good fight, the Hebrews
    themselves acted differently. Love or money wouldn’t budge them from the comforts of home,
    from their indifference. To their brothers who felt the brunt of King Jabin’s onslaught, the tribes
    turned a cold shoulder.

    In the vacuum, in the breach, the God of Israel appeared. “They fought from heaven, the stars
    in their courses fought against Sisera.” The Maker took the field, in a manner of speaking, to
    defeat Jabin and Sisera. In addition to God’s help from above, He also enlisted nature below.
    “The brook Kishon swept them away, that ancient brook, the brook Kishon. O my soul, tread
    them down with strength.” Rushing waters swept away Canaanite warriors. Abravanel contends
    that the decisive battle between Deborah and Barak’s troops and those of Jabin and Sisera took
    place at river’s edge. Yet, for enemy troops either wanting to flee or join the fight, mighty
    waters waved – decimating them. How? River banks flooded the area, miraculously. Chariots of
    iron stuck in the mud, where wheels became decoupled from the chassis. Thus, for Abravanel,
    “that ancient brook” alludes to those other bodies of waters that brought storied victories to
    the Jewish nation. We refer to the splitting of the Red Sea, as well as the parting of the Jordan
    River.

    Here, in Judges, it was the brook of Kishon that bamboozled the enemy. Miraculously, for all
    the damage and chaos Kishon’s waters perpetrated against the Canaanites, the Hebrews had
    not been harmed in the least bit. For them, fording the fickle brook water was, well easy as pie.

    ”O my soul, tread them down with strength.” Deborah exclaims that from the great victory at
    Kishon, her soul exults. The prophetess refers to the river wreaking havoc with the enemy
    (albeit kind to the Jews). “Then did the horse hoofs stamp by reason of the prancing, the
    prancing of their mighty ones.” Kishon knew which horses to pass, and which to bewitch.

  • Judges 6: Gideon Son of Joash (aka Jerubbaal)

    After Deborah the prophetess passed away, the Hebrews returned to their evil ways. This,
    predictably, provoked the Maker’s ire. And so, He emboldened the Jews’ adversaries: “And the
    hand of Midian prevailed against Israel; and because of Midian the Children of Israel made
    them the dens which are in the mountains, and the caves, and the strongholds.” For Abravanel,
    Judges 6 offers a close glimpse into just how wretched life had become for the backsliding
    Hebrews. Unbearable.

    “And the Children of Israel did that which was evil in the sight of the LORD; and
    the LORD delivered them into the hand of Midian seven years.”

    “And so it was, when Israel had sown, that the Midianites came up, and the Amalekites, and the
    children of the east; they came up against them; and they encamped against them, and
    destroyed the produce of the earth, till you come unto Gaza, and left no sustenance in Israel,
    neither sheep, nor ox, nor ass.” Midian and company either consumed Israeli produce or
    rendered it inedible. Jewish livestock, too, fared no better, as hordes of enemies brought their
    domesticated animals to participate in the bloodbath. “For they came up with their cattle and
    their tents, and they came in as locusts for multitude; both they and their camels were without
    number; and they came into the land to destroy it.”

    Abravanel leads with something positive, citing the Jewish sages. “And the Children of Israel did
    that which was evil…”The verse does not say, “And the Children of Israel added to their evil.”
    There is an important lesson. Namely, all prior ill-conduct had been forgiven. What curried
    Heaven’s pardon? It was on the merit of Deborah’s song. After that high-water religious
    outpouring, the slate had been cleared.

    Sadly, though, the Jews lapsed, doing “evil in the sight of the LORD.”Fast and furious, Midian
    moved in for the kill. For the Hebrews, life went underground. Literally. “The Children of Israel
    made…dens in the mountains, and the caves…” This refers to subterranean hideouts, with
    hardly any fresh air or sunlight.

    Ever so discretely, Jewish farmers planted crops. To no avail. At first sight of plant growth,
    enemies swooped down “and destroyed the produce of the earth.” Nothing remained. That
    was only the half of it. Midian and its allies attacked the Hebrews’ livestock, leaving “neither
    sheep, nor ox, nor ass.” Either the marauders ran off with the animals or killed them.

    In a word, the Jews were humbled, broken. Abravanel paints more of the savage scenes.
    Midian’s troops arrived on fleet-footed horses, accompanied by a bevy of animals, including
    “their camels…and they came into the land to destroy it.” Mercilessly, Midianites and
    Amalekites systematically starved Jews.

    “And Israel was brought very low because of Midian; and the Children of Israel cried unto the
    LORD.” Sincere tears; heartfelt contrition. God heeded their wailing. In response “the LORD sent
    a prophet unto the Children of Israel; and he said unto them: Thus says the LORD, the God of
    Israel: I brought you up from Egypt, and brought you forth out of the house of bondage.”

    With this prophetic opening message, God dispatched a seer to tap the man, who would judge
    the nation and deliver them from their plight, from their hell. Gideon son of Joash, also called
    Jerubbaal, an unlikely choice to turn the tide against his brethren’s enemies, did just that, as
    this and the ensuing chapters teach.

  • Judges 7: Gideon’s War

    Abravanel uses the previous chapter (Judges 6) to get a better grip on our chapter. Recall,
    Judges 6 concluded with the outward miracle by way of fleece of wool, as per Gideon’s request
    of God. A divine message to Gideon conveyed that he would emerge victorious over the
    Midianites.

    “Then Jerubbaal, who is Gideon, and all the people that were with him, rose up
    early, and pitched beside En-harod; and the camp of Midian was on the north
    side of them, by Gibeath-moreh, in the valley. And the LORD said unto Gideon:
    The people that are with you are too many for Me to give the Midianites into
    their hand, lest Israel vaunt themselves against Me, saying: mine own hand has
    saved me.”

    Judges 7 opens with Gideon’s war preparations, one that centered on enlisting and mobilizing a
    sizeable army. God had different ideas: “And the LORD said unto Gideon: The people that are
    with you are too many for Me to give the Midianites into their hand…” The Maker even
    provided the rationale for a much-downsized army. “Lest Israel vaunt themselves against Me,
    saying: mine own hand has saved me.”

    God continues whittling away at Gideon’s army, paring it down to nubbins. “Now therefore
    make proclamation in the ears of the people, saying: Whosoever is fearful and trembling, let
    him return and depart early from mount Gilead. And there returned of the people twenty and
    two thousand; and there remained ten thousand.”

    Abravanel explains why the Creator required Gideon to make drastic cuts in the army size. He
    also sheds light on the method whereby the number of troops would be released from army
    service. “And the LORD said unto Gideon: The people are yet too many. Bring them down unto
    the water, and I will try them for you there; and it shall be, that of whom I say to you: This shall
    go with you, the same shall go with you; and of whomsoever I say unto you: This shall not go
    with you, the same shall not go.”

    Early in the morning after the fleece of wool miracle (actually two fleece miracles transpired),
    Gideon and his men woke up. God came to the Hebrew judge, informing him that the army size
    was too large. As quoted above, the “official reason” had to do with Hebrews not misconstruing
    the upcoming military victory, taking credit. That, Abravanel learns, sidestepped the real reason
    for cutting the army size. The Maker understood that many soldiers were fearful of the
    imminent war with Midian. Hence, Heaven deemed it an expedient to let the faint of heart go
    home. Deuteronomy 20 makes explicit: All men who fear that their sins will cause them to fall
    in battle are exempt. Here in Judges, owing to the large number of men engaged in paganism,
    they certainly feared divine payback on the battle field.

    Accordingly, God ordered Gideon to proclaim: “Whosoever is fearful and trembling, let him
    return…”The Creator did not want to draw attention to these soft-hearted men. “Let him
    return and depart early…” For Abravanel, the point is clear. God demanded them to depart the
    camp quietly, under cover of the wee hours of dawn. Why? Only the cowardly refuse army
    service; it’s humiliating.

    How widespread was the phenomenon of weak-kneed Hebrews at that time? Numbers speak
    for themselves. Gideon began with thirty-two thousand troops. Twenty-two thousand
    disappeared at sunrise. That left ten thousand. God did not desire them, and so He devised a
    test to weed out the masses. “So he brought down the people unto the water; and the LORD
    said unto Gideon: Everyone that laps of the water with his tongue, as a dog laps, him shall you
    set by himself; likewise, every one that bows down upon his knees to drink.”

    Abravanel provides his rationale for Heaven’s trial by the river, but for brevity we omit it here.
    Note here, though, the number of troops deemed unworthy or unwilling to join the war efforts.
    Put differently, of the original thirty-two thousand men, how many did the Creator allow to
    fight? “And the number of them that lapped, putting their hand to their mouth, was three
    hundred men; but all the rest of the people bowed down upon their knees to drink water.”

    Gideon inspected his remaining warriors. He might have experienced a sinking feeling. Now, he
    beheld and inspected not an army, nor even a division. Instead, his fighting troops barely
    registered the size of a small battalion. God dd not want Gideon to fret, and so delivered a
    promise: “And the LORD said unto Gideon: By the three hundred men that lapped will I save
    you, and deliver the Midianites into your hand; and let all the people go every man unto his
    place.”

  • Judges 8: Gideon and Ephraim

    As we saw in the previous chapter, God pulled a resounding victory over Midian, the Hebrew
    troops under Gideon acting in cameo roles. Taking the field were the judge’s three hundred
    men. Yet, they were not the only participants. The earlier chapter also gives a shout-out to the
    tribes of Naphtali, Asher, and Menasseh for their part in pursuing the routed Midianites.

    “And the men of Ephraim said unto him: Why have you served us thus, that you
    did not call us when you went to fight with Midian? And they did chide with him
    sharply.”

    In fact, the concluding verses of Judges 7 also extends honorable mention to the tribe of
    Ephraim. Nevertheless, Abravanel writes, Ephraim had choice words for Gideon, as our
    chapter’s lead verse records. “And the men of Ephraim said unto him: Why have you served us
    thus, that you did not call us when you went to fight Midian? And they did chide him sharply.”

    On the surface, Ephraim’s complaint doesn’t make sense, Abravanel notes. Well, what was their
    gripe? Gideon had included Ephraim in the smashing victory over Midian. “And Gideon sent
    messengers throughout all the hill-country of Ephraim, saying: Come down against Midian, and
    take before them the waters, as far as Beth-barah, and also the Jordan. So, all the men of
    Ephraim were gathered together, and took the waters as far as Beth-barah, and also the
    Jordan.”

    Here is the point. Ephraim earned high marks in the war against Midian. “And they took the two
    princes of Midian, Oreb and Zeeb; and they slew Oreb at the Rock of Oreb, and Zeeb they slew
    at the Winepress of Zeeb, and pursued Midian; and they brought the heads of Oreb and Zeeb to
    Gideon beyond the Jordan.”Still and all, Ephraim harbored deep resentment for Gideon. “Why
    have you served us thus…”

    Ephraim felt indignation because they believed that Gideon’s call to Ephraim for assistance
    came late in the game, meaning after the main thrust of the battle had already been launched.
    That is, Ephraim complained that Gideon enlisted Ephraim for the purpose of chasing Midian’s
    defeated and fleeing army. For courageous warriors, Ephraim asserted, nothing could be more
    insulting. They were willing and able to take an active part in the toe-to toe combat. Thus,
    Ephraim’s job of merely chasing Midian represented a slight to their manliness, chivalry. “And
    they did chide with him sharply.”

    Ruthless fighters, such as the men of Ephraim, could not abide Gideon’s affront, one that stung
    like a slap. They insisted that Gideon should have mobilized them at the outset of the war, not
    its conclusion.

    Gideon immediately sought to right the wrong. “And he said unto them: What have I now done
    in comparison with you? Is not the gleaning of Ephraim better than the vintage of Abiezer? God
    has delivered into your hand the princes of Midian, Oreb and Zeeb; and what was I able to do in
    comparison with you?”Gideon downplayed his own role in the war with Midian. At the same
    time, the Hebrew judge praised Ephraim’s contribution to the hilt. “What was I able to do in
    comparison with you?”, referring to Midian’s highest-ranking officers that Ephraim captured.
    “God has delivered into your hands the princes of Midian, Oreb and Zeeb…” Militarily speaking,
    Gideon acknowledged, that while Ephraim took on Midian’s most formidable commanders, he
    himself fought against a ragtag, Midianite encampment.

    “Is not the gleaning of Ephraim better than the vintage of Abiezer?” Gideon’s extolment,
    essentially a reframing of the events of the war, pleased Ephraim. Reconciliation followed.
    “Then their anger was abated toward him, when he had said that.”

Page 1 of 2